Crunchy peanut shells filled with PB cream. Discontinued in 1998 due to costly production. Fans still petition for their return!

1. PB Crisps

Banne d for excessive caffeine, it fueled sleepovers until 2003. Briefly revived in 2014—then axed again. 

2. Surge 

Extreme citrus and cinnamon sours. Discontinued in 2010 after melting their packaging. Fans say they’d risk enamel damage for one more tin! 

3. Altoids Sour

The ONLY cereal with real Oreo bits. Gone in the U.S. (still sold in Korea!). Petition to #BringBackOreoOs has 50K+ signatures! 

4. Oreo O’s

Hollow, air-puffed chips launched in 1994. Fans blame their demise on ’too much air’—but we’d empty our allowance for them! 

5. 3D Dorito

Tiny Butterfinger balls discontinued in 2006. Rumor: They clogged vending machines. Why not just sell them in bags?! 

6. Butterfinger BB’s

The creamiest frozen treat. Sales crashed after Cosby’s scandal, but fans swear the recipe needs a rebrand. 

7. Jell-O Pudding Pop

Chewy, fudgy bars sold for $1. Discontinued in 2004—now even employees don’t remember them. Justice for BK sweets! 

8. Burger King’s Dessert Bar

2021’s reboot flopped—fans say the frosting tastes like glue. Original ’90s recipe? Lost forever. 😭 RIP childhood. 

9. Dunkaroo

Coke’s 1994 ‘anti-brand’ soda with depressing art and a 1-800-I-FEEL-OK hotline. Lasted 2 years. Tasted like carbonated regret.

10. OK Soda